Skip to main content

Mitchell Robinson is a Celtics Trojan Horse until proven otherwise

The Celtics don't have to worry about Robinson for now, but his poor play is the only anchor weighing them down.
ByMatt John
Nov 10, 2026; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Boston Celtics center Mitchell Robinson (4) looks on during the second quarter against the Philadelphia 76ers at Xfinity Mobile Arena. Mandatory Credit: Bill Streicher-Imagn Images
Nov 10, 2026; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Boston Celtics center Mitchell Robinson (4) looks on during the second quarter against the Philadelphia 76ers at Xfinity Mobile Arena. Mandatory Credit: Bill Streicher-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

There really isn't much to complain about with the Boston Celtics this season. They are 11-3 with the NBA's best net rating of 12.1, with the fourth-best offensive rating and second-best defensive rating. Their schedule hasn't exactly been hard, but at least they're not just beating the easy competition, but beating the crap out of them.

Among the very few complaints about Boston one month into the season has been Mitchell Robinson's poor play. On paper, Robinson should have been a perfect fit for Mazzulla Ball. A dominant rebounder on both sides of the ball (especially on offense) and a defensive playmaker who helped New York win its first title in decades, Robinson should have given Boston the edge they needed to return to contention.

But that hasn't been the case. It's one thing if Robinson had simply been neutral in his impact for the Celtics, but nope, he's negative all-around to the point that he's earned the label of Trojan Horse until he improves all-around. Out of all the Celtics rotation players, Robinson has the worst net rating on the team by a mile.

The Celtics' net rating when he's on the floor is bad (minus-5.3), and they are dominant when he's off the floor (plus-21.3). When it all adds up, the Celtics net rating with Robinson is minus-26.6. Compare that to, say, Jordan Walsh, who's next up in terms of worst net rating among the Celtics' rotation players. Yes, the Celtics' net rating is better when he's off the floor (plus-17.2), but they're just fine when he's on the floor (plus-2.8).

But oh boy, the Robinson factor actually makes Walsh look worse than he really is, furthering the Trojan Horse argument. And he's not the only one. Barstool Sports' Dan Greenberg pointed out that Walsh, Hugo Gonzalez, Payton Pritchard, and Jayson Tatum have all seen their impact negatively affected by Robinson.

The Celtics net rating with Robinson and Walsh is minus-15.3, but remove Robinson, and it vaults to plus-14.1. Their net rating with Robinson and Gonzalez is minus-23.6, but without Robinson, it's a plus-10.8. Their net rating with Robinson and Pritchard is minus-9.3. Without Robinson, it's plus-21.9. With Tatum, it goes from minus-6.4 with Robinson to plus-21.8 without him.

There's enough empirical data to confirm they're bad when Robinson's on the floor and awesome when he's off it.

His rim protection numbers are bad too

Boston's loss to Orlando the other night was yet another example of the ugly truth of how much worse they are with Robinson (and how much better they are with Neemias Queta). It's not like it was entirely Robinson's fault, but he provided very little resistance as the Magic went off for 40 in the worst defensive quarter of the season.

Following that monstrosity, Hoopology's Justin Pinnix revealed that opponents shoot 19% better when Robinson is on the floor and 13% worse when Queta is on the floor. The evidence of Robinson's poor play isn't just conclusive. It's overwhelming.

Robinson said on Media Day that he would need 20 games to get comfortable. Again, if his numbers were neutral, then he would deserve grace, but this hasn't been a "nothing" impact. It's been negative, and it's becoming hard to figure out how it gets better.

It's not over for Robinson, but he's got a lot of ground to make up. It can't be just one game, either. It has to be a stretch to give the Celtics confidence that he'll get his groove back.

Add us as a preferred source on Google