The All-NBA First Team vote of Jimmy Butler from ESPN’s Tim Bontemps baffled Boston Celtics analyst Dan Greenberg. Bontemps informed Max Kellerman on his show of his vote, which has an effect on both Jayson Tatum and Jaylen Brown in their next contract negotiations due to the CBA’s All-NBA tie-ins to contract extensions.
I'm sorry what? https://t.co/ESvS1VaYen
— Dan Greenberg (@StoolGreenie) April 11, 2023
This comes less than a year after Bontemps voted for Jimmy Butler for the 2022 Eastern Conference Finals MVP:
How the results came in for the Eastern Conference Finals MVP. pic.twitter.com/iL4ivzaYFu
— Chris Haynes (@ChrisBHaynes) May 30, 2022
The St. Bonaventure graduate and New York native has an interesting voting pattern that typically winds up working out well for Butler but comes at the expense of Tatum — and in this case, Brown as well. Weird.
Boston Celtics fans not happy with All-NBA snubs
With Brown’s future earnings with the Boston Celtics on the line, fans were not happy with Bontemps’ Butler vote:
Wait, did @TimBontemps really just vote for Jimmy Butler over Jayson Tatum for 1st team All NBA?? Why do guys like Tim have a vote again? Tells you everything you need to know about the award 🤮
— Rahul Sheth (@rksheth9) April 11, 2023
Unserious @TimBontemps https://t.co/TbPwLB49se
— Brad Auerbach (@CelticsPost) April 11, 2023
I legit don’t know what Jimmy is better at than Tatum this season. https://t.co/86LRljVns7
— Andrew (@AndrewRiffe1) April 11, 2023
That checks out, he hates the Celtics
— Pat Bradley ☘️🏀💰🏈 (@PatBradley_) April 11, 2023
Why most post season awards are meaningless
— Matt (@MLG0944) April 11, 2023
Drug test him
— ☘️Full Court D☘️ (@C0urtneyDanvers) April 11, 2023
That is absolutely insane on every possible level. What a hater lol not sure he should have a vote
— TheNBANinja (@theNBAninja) April 11, 2023
Ultimately, voters have their own criteria, which makes it difficult to decipher bias from writer to writer. Not to mention, All-NBA awards likely mean less to most players than team success. But Brown having less incentive to sign with the Celtics and hosting a bidding war for his services is ultimately good for ratings.
ESPN’s included.